Cayuga NY Real Estate & Homes for Sale

Welcome to 105 Virginia St, a truly exceptional 1850's home in the heart of Waterloo! This stunning 4,816 square foot home offers endless possibilities. Boasting 5 bedrooms and 2.5 baths, this spacious residence provides ample room for comfortable living. As you step inside, you'll be greeted by intricate woodwork and a formal entry that exudes grandeur. The interior is adorned with beautiful stained glass, adding a touch of artistry to the home's character. With 5 fireplaces, this dwelling creates a warm and inviting ambiance throughout. The cut stone and brick facade and wrap-around porch further enhance the curb appeal, making it a sight to behold. The massive timber frame attic offers endless possibilities, whether you envision it as office space, a charming bed and breakfast, or a sprawling family home. There is just too much to describe. It is a must see! Don't miss the opportunity to own this architectural gem on Virginia St.

Cayuga Lake Compound. Real Estate Offering consisting of Farmhouse, Cottage with 417' of lake frontage & commercial buildings all on 50 acres overlooking Cayuga Lake. Farmhouse was built in early 1800's and has been extensively renovated / expanded. Cottage offers opportunity for income stream as it's currently rented year-round on a seasonal basis. Commercial Buildings are currently being used to operate a small winery. Though the business is included in the real estate offering, these buildings have flexibility to be used for other uses whether it be commercial or personal use or leased out. Excess land offers opportunity to be leased to nearby farmers. Sales Flyer accompanies listing. Video and other information available upon request.

The 1925 house on a .12-acre property with a small lake view exudes classic charm and architectural character. Original hardwood floors (freshly painted) grace the home's 2nd floor and some first floor spaces. Indulge in the character of the radiant heat registers while taking comfort in the newer roof and siding, in addition to the newer electric and vinyl windows + municipal water! Just picture what you can do in the rustic, expansive kitchen space overlooking the wrap around porch with small but picturesque views of Cayuga lake. With room to improve the walk up attic space above the kitchen area, this home encourages you to bring your customization plans! The first floor full and only full bath is renovated with laundry. It provides a unique glimpse into the architectural aesthetics of the 1920s while offering a cozy, inviting space with room to make it your own.(currently leased until March 2024 at $1500/month tenant pays all except property taxes and trash removal)

Welcome to this exquisite and unique property that offers a perfect blend of easy living and modern amenities, situated on a sprawling 17.61 acres with a serene lake view and incredible accessory building: Small Pockets Farm. The ranch-style home features 3 bedrooms and 1.5 baths, exuding warmth and comfort. The open-concept living area boasts abundant natural light, highlighting the beautiful floors and a lake view, making it an inviting space for both relaxation and entertaining.With 17.61 acres at your disposal, there's no shortage of outdoor possibilities. There are established trails and a fire pit. This property offers endless potential for enjoying the beauty of the great outdoors.The true gem of this property is the thoughtfully designed accessory building. Built to code, it's a beer and cider tasting room that also boasts video games and a TV. Sale can include turnkey licensed tasting room & production equipment -negotiable.

Have you dreamed of the perfect old farmhouse? This house has a plank floor entryway, and hardwood floors on the first and second floors. An iconic side porch to living or kitchen area. beautiful kitchen and formal dining room. 4 Bedrooms on the second floor, and a perfect location for a second bath.3rd level has been almost finished. 2 additional rooms. Apple trees and many specimen trees. Large 4 Car garage.

Welcome to 765 Poplar Ridge Rd in Aurora! This charming property offers the perfect blend of serene countryside living and modern conveniences. Situated on a generous 1.4-acre lot, this 1,680 sq ft home features 3 bedrooms and 2 baths, providing ample space for a growing family or those seeking a peaceful retreat. The property boasts a unique two-story barn/workshop, perfect for storage or creative pursuits. Take in pastoral, sunset, and lake views from the observation tower. Outside, you'll also find two storage sheds, plenty of flower beds, blacktop driveway ensures easy access and snow removal. Stay comfortable year-round with the split mini air conditioner, and enjoy the convenience of a first-floor laundry. Located just outside of Aurora and close to Cayuga Lake and Long Point State Park. This is an opportunity not to be missed!

Looking for that charming and quaint weekend getaway on Cayuga Lake!? It is available and seeks its next owner. Create your own slice of paradise on this 46ft of lake front, with concrete break wall and dock ideal for swimming, lounging, and boating. A few minor updates, and the next owners touch can make this an oasis for relaxation. There is plenty of space inside and out including a large, covered porch to enjoy those beautiful Cayuga Lake Sunrises, and to get out of the afternoon sun while you still enjoy the fun. Just a short walk or kayak paddle to the VanRiper Conservation Area & Whitlock Nature Preserve. Close proximity to both the Cayuga and Seneca Lake Wine Trails where you will enjoy local wineries, breweries and dining in the Finger Lakes Region. Experience life in the Finger Lakes, one of the most beautiful places in NY. Life is better on the lake!

This 6-bedroom luxury home with 3 levels of entertainment and living space has everything you're looking for. Turn-key, fully furnished. Two-story entry foyer, Brazilian teak floors and exquisite lake views from the great room. Two-sided gas fireplace with formal dining area. Open kitchen layout with custom cabinetry, granite counters and eat-in breakfast space. First-floor primary bedroom with ensuite bath and private balcony. Completing the entry level is a second bedroom and full bath. Upstairs has three bedrooms and full bath. The lower level includes a family room w/pool table, kitchenette, bed/bath and easy access to the lakeside patio. Other features - 1st floor laundry, expansive deck, 3-bay garage with attic storage, workshop and more. Outside, you can easily run right into the lake with no steps. Waiting for you is 77 feet of level beach and a low maintenance dock w/covered boat hoist. Public water and sewer. Delayed showings begin June 18th.

This 1870 Majestic Four Pillar Greek Revival home w/over 3100 sq ft features Formal Rooms, Large Plank Floors, Large Vertical Windows, High Ceilings, 4 En Suite Bedrooms, (4 full baths) & half bath. There's a beautiful mix of modern amenities w/classic charm, historic details & character of the famous Greek Revival Style. Updated kitchen w/Island, all New Appliances, Custom Ceramic Tiled floor (Radiant Heat), Breakfast Nook which opens to the Family Room w/3 Double Doors leading to spacious Private Back Deck (Perfect for entertaining). Formal Dining Room, Formal Living Room w/brick fireplace, & Formal entry are classic original spaces. The En Suites one on Main Level, and Three on the upper level make for perfect guest quarters - The property was a private residence then a unique Bed & Breakfast in country setting & could be again! Detached 2 car garage with upper level storage, & large barn w/metal roof. Convenient location to Aurora, Cayuga Lake, Ithaca, Auburn, & Cortland.

Fully furnished 6-bedroom home offering 100 feet of beachfront on the picturesque Cayuga lake. Whether you're seeking a year-round haven or a lucrative short-term rental opportunity, this property has it all. As you arrive, find ample parking at the top. From there, descend via a set of stairs or, for ultimate convenience, take the inclinator, and soak in the views. Step inside to a spacious, well-appointed kitchen where granite countertop space abounds. The open-concept 1st floor boasts a generous living area with an abundance of windows that frame the lake views from nearly every angle. There's also a dedicated dining area, den, full bath, and two cozy bedrooms and 1/2 bath. Venture upstairs, discover 4 more generously sized bedrooms, each exuding comfort & style. Another full bath, and one of the bedrooms offers sliders to a private balcony a perfect spot to savor the views. A loft space upstairs allows for versatile use for whatever your heart desires. Outside, a spacious deck, boat hoist and dock. Nestled in the heart of Finger Lakes wine country, this home offers proximity to the region's renowned wine trails, hiking, and all the enchanting experiences the area has to offer.

If a comfortable, clean, like new home is your goal, you have got to see this property! There is nothing like it for sale in the area. A standalone Ranch home with municipal water/sewer, this gem on 1.6 acres combines the best of country and village life. A great kitchen and dining/living room offer pastoral views of fields and a peek at Seneca lake. 4 roomy bedrooms with great closets share an updated bath in the hall. Mostly new flooring on this main level is easy-care luxury vinyl and plush carpeting. Two newly refinished decks are waiting for your patio furniture! Raised bed gardens are established and ready to produce all you need for a household. Fruit trees are starting to bud, and a garden shed will help store the tools and mower. The lower level of this home is a wonderful open 1700+ SF, finished and conditioned by baseboard heat, with a walk out door to the backyard plus a full bath. A rec room, guest quarters, library or workshop are all possible. Conveniently located near Ovid village amenities and Seneca lake. Short commute to Ithaca, Watkins Glen, Geneva, Rochester & Syracuse. Ask for the list of improvements!

A spectacular property on Cayuga Lake!! This property has NEVER been on the market for over 75 years. The current owners are running it as an Bed & Breakfast. There is a main house with 6 suites and there are 4 other cottages that have from 1 to 3 bedrooms in each cottage. This would be a spectacular family compound. The view from the front porch of the main house is beautiful. It allows you to see the sun rise and the sun set. This property will not last long!!

Affordable opportunity! Looking to build your rental portfolio while on a budget? This Ranch offers main level living, which is sought-after by many. Additionally, it is privately set in just over 1 acre with a seasonal pond. Currently rented month-to-month. With a vision and some modern updates this could be a great starter home, or a short term or long term rental. New roof on sunroom. Newer windows. Full, unfinished basement. Expansive back deck. Pool as is. In the heart of the Finger Lakes, close to Cayuga Lake, and short drive to Seneca Lake!

Charming 1880's Italianate style home with 2700+ sq ft this home offers unique blend of historic charm, modern comforts, & outdoor amenities, makes it ideal retreat for those seeking a stylish living experience. Greeted by the elegance of 8-foot ceilings on the main level, tall windows, plenty of light and beautiful natural woodwork throughout the home. Featuring 4 bedrooms & 2 full baths, this historic property has been thoughtfully renovated in 2023, including the addition of luxurious primary suite, w/large walk in shower, soaking tub, double custom vanity, changing room & walk in closet. Spacious layout offers a perfect blend of modern amenities & classic architectural details. On 1.4 acres of land, providing ample space for outdoor activities & relaxation with in-ground pool, pool house privacy fence, perfect for cooling off and entertaining guests. Two-story barn, offering two bays for parking, storage or potential for a workshop. Chain link fencing for pets, and a large level yard. Private office space on 2nd floor, and or guest room. Laundry on 1st level. Public water, walk to store, and EZ commute to Ithaca, Auburn and Cortland. Credit available for front hall.

Discover the timeless allure of this 1890s farmhouse nestled on a generous 2-acre parcel. This historic gem is an opportunity for those with a vision, ready to bring back its original charm. Step inside to discover original hardwood floors, a king sized kitchen, first floor full bathroom, tall ceilings, and some rooms gutted and ready to be finished. Updates include a new metal roof, some new windows and new vinyl siding. This old farmhouse is a perfect project for those who appreciate history and have an eye for potential.The spacious lot provides ample space for gardening, expansion, or a rural retreat.With the right vision and effort, this farmhouse could be lovingly restored to its former glory, preserving a piece of the past for future generations to enjoy.

Open House Sunday 8/6/23 starts at 11:30 am-1pm. THIS is TRULY IT! Meticulously Maintained farmhouse with careful consideration of restoration and a beautiful balance of old and new. The kitchen is the central focus and energy with spacious countertops, sitting Island, walls of cupboards, new appliances, and large walk in pantry. Features To Numerous to share all, Formal Dining, Formal Living, Family Room, 3/4 Bedrooms, 2 Bathrooms, Hardwood floors, Old wide Plank floors, Double Pane Windows, Soaking Tub, Standing Shower, 1st floor Laundry, Built in Office Nook, High Speed Internet, Public Water, Newer 3 Bay Garage with 2nd Level Storage, Buderus Boiler, Easy to Convert Main Level Bedroom, Mud Room, Expansive 10 x 40 Eastern Exposure Sitting Deck for BBQ, Mature Trees, Covered Front Porch, Work shop in Garage, Farm land on 3 sides, Level Lawn, Gardens, Convenient location 30 mins to Ithaca, Cortland & Auburn. This may "Check All Criteria Boxes"! Don't miss this well cared for home!

Land, Farm, LAND, FARM. A long gravel drive takes you to this private setting for this custom built two level ranch home with Cathedral ceilings, a primary suite and two levels of living space. There are 5 bedrooms in total with a primary Suite and 2 full baths. There are 3 bedrooms on the main level and 2 bedrooms with proper egress on the lower level, or will also work as private home office space. The poured concrete walls have created a dry lower level walk out on grade. Supplemental wood stove capable of heating all on lower level. Tremendous amount of storage, large windows, bonus rooms, covered front porch, mudroom, laundry on primary level. Beautiful large room with three walls of windows taking in fields, trees, and sun. The agricultural barn, houses horses with walkout pastures, electrified fencing, separated pastures and hayfield. Yard with plenty of room for gardens. Incredibly easy commute to downtown Skaneateles, and short distance to Auburn, Syracuse, Cortland, and Ithaca. Buyer allowance for updates available towards buyers prepaids or closing costs.

Discover The Glass Magnolia, a charming Finger Lakes B&B! With 11 cozy guest suites, private baths, spacious owner's quarters and communal dining. TripAdvisor awarded. Most weekends booked mid-Spring to Fall, offering great income potential. Pet-friendly rooms with private baths and exterior exits. Sale includes furnishings. Residential with commercial use, municipal water/sewer, Just a mile from Cayuga Lake, 5 miles from Seneca Lake, in a vibrant neighborhood. Sold with 8347 Main St. By appointment only. Own a slice of Finger Lakes hospitality!

Discover The Glass Magnolia, a charming Finger Lakes B&B! 8347 Main St. is known as the Guest or companion house to 8339 and is available by itself as a separate purchase. TripAdvisor awarded. Most weekends booked mid-Spring to Fall, offering great income potential. With its own full kitchen and laundry, this home is often rented "whole house" and is a good money maker for the business. Carriage house included. New roof in 2023. Sale includes furnishings. Residential with commercial use, municipal water/sewer, in a vibrant neighborhood. By appointment only. Own a slice of Finger Lakes hospitality!

Customized, 4 bedroom, 2 full bath Cape on tiered double lot. Three bedrooms on the main level and a semi private suite in the upper level and access to a the back deck. Large living room with Western valley views. Large versatile dining in the center of the home with direct access to a covered front sitting porch. Pleasant versatile floor plan with a large kitchen area. Two tax parcels make up this property and there is enclosed fencing, a large shed, a turn around parking area, and yard bordered by trees. A Convenient commute to Moravia, Auburn, Ithaca & Cortland.

3 unit investment property located in the Village of Interlaken. A true moneymaker! This property features a single family 1 bedroom cottage and 2 mobile homes with 2 bedrooms each. All 3 units have municipal services! This is a well priced straightforward turnkey property for a savvy investor. Or you can live in the cute little cottage for free and let the mobile home rentals pay your mortgage. This is a well kept property and sits privately away from the road. The cottage is privately situated from the mobile homes.There is a great rental history with month to month leases. The size of the cottage is 546 Square Feet. The Mobile Homes are about 938 square feet each.

Opportunity awaits! At over 3000 square feet and 5 bedrooms, this property could remain a large single family home, OR easily be turned in to a multi unit for the savvy investor. Located just outside the Village of Interlaken, this property sits on over an acre of land with a barn and additional outbuilding, gardens and a partially fenced in yard. Less than 10 minutes to Trumansburg and only 20 minutes to Cayuga Medical Center!

Delayed negotiations 5/14/24 @ 10am. Your DREAM home awaits! This lovely 3 bedroom, 1 bathroom home situated on 9.6 acres including pastures, a garden, 2 car garage and a beautiful barn! This home is ready for its new owners!

Farm Living is the life for me! 1388 Ridge Rd was working Goat Farm Plus until 2024. This property features a 4 Bedroom/2 Bathroom Victorian Farmhouse with updates and original details. The 2-story barn held goats and chickens, historically a milking barn & housed horses. There is 10+ acres. The sellers have made many updates: fenced the perimeter, added a farm Stand with Electric & separate Public Entrance, created a Board of Heath certified Cheese Room, attached to municipal water, updated electric, installed heat pump heating, renovated Kitchen, made it solar ready, created organic gardens with berries and perennials, new metal roof on barn, and more! The sellers sold cheese, yogurt, produce, flowers at the ITH market & through the on-site Farm Stand. There's too much to list! Please see the documents and videos. Easy to see for qualified buyers!

Charming Convenient Country Cape and 24'x30' Pole Barn in the Town of Locke. Three Bedrooms & A Full Bath, Laundry on Upper Level (no scary cellar laundry!), a custom-built Large Room we are calling a Family Room, historically a Home Business Hair Salon with direct access door. Great potential for home office, additional home space or a main level bedroom. XL Living Room located on the northside of home with Great Light. There are 3 bedrooms and full bath on the upper level. Paved drive with dual entry and a large Detached Garage/Pole Barn. Kitchen and Dining Room Combination, please open cabinets, lots of smart storage spaces. Public water & NYSEG gas lines. Located in Moravia School Central Schools. Excellent commutable distance to Ithaca, Auburn and Cortland. Easy to see for qualified buyers! Call your Buyers Agent NOW!